A “one-upper” is someone who seems to have an innate need to outdo everyone else in conversation, often turning every shared story or achievement into a competition.
Whether it’s boasting about a bigger vacation, a more impressive job, or a tougher struggle, one-uppers have an uncanny ability to redirect the spotlight onto themselves.
While their behavior might stem from insecurity, a desire for validation, or simply an overactive competitive streak, it can leave others feeling overshadowed or dismissed. Interacting with a one-upper can be frustrating, but understanding their motivations can offer insights into how to navigate these conversations with patience and grace.
HERE ARE THE TOP SIGNS OF A ONE-UPPER:
Always Outdoes Your Achievements
No matter what accomplishment you share, they have a bigger, better, or more impressive story. For example, if you ran a 5K, they ran a marathon.
Turns Struggles Into Competitions
They don’t just empathize with your challenges—they top them. If you mention being tired after a long day, they’ll counter with how they haven’t slept in three days.
Consistently Redirects Conversations
Conversations frequently shift to focus on their experiences or stories, often at the expense of others’ moments to share.
Exaggerates to Seem Superior
Their anecdotes or claims often feel overly embellished, as if they’re trying too hard to impress.
Dismisses Your Experiences
Instead of acknowledging or validating your story, they jump straight to theirs, making your experiences feel less significant.
Competes Over Minor Details
Even small, everyday occurrences become competitions. If you say it was hot outside, they’ll insist it was hotter where they were.
Dominates Group Settings
In group conversations, they often try to take center stage, steering discussions to highlight their own achievements or hardships.
Rarely Shows Genuine Interest in Others
They seldom ask follow-up questions or engage meaningfully with what you’re saying unless it gives them a chance to outshine you.
If someone displays several of these behaviors consistently, they might be a classic one-upper. Recognizing these signs can help you manage interactions with them effectively.
THE BEHAVIOR OF A ONE-UPPER OFTEN STEMS FROM DEEPER PSYCHOLOGICAL OR EMOTIONAL ISSUES, THOUGH THE REASONS CAN VARY. HERE ARE SOME OF THE COMMON UNDERLYING FACTORS:
Insecurity and Low Self-Esteem
One-uppers may feel inadequate, or fear being perceived as unimportant. By constantly outdoing others, they seek validation and reassurance of their worth.
Need for Attention
Some people crave being the center of attention and use one-upping as a way to keep the spotlight on themselves.
Competitiveness
For others, one-upping is a manifestation of an overly competitive nature. They feel compelled to “win” conversations, even if it’s not an actual contest.
Lack of Empathy or Social Awareness
They may struggle to understand how their behavior affects others or fail to recognize when it’s time to listen instead of talk.
Childhood Experiences
If they grew up in an environment where achievements were constantly compared or they felt overshadowed, they may have developed a habit of trying to outshine others as a defense mechanism.
Unconscious Behavior
Some one-uppers aren’t even aware they’re doing it. They might genuinely think they’re contributing to the conversation, not realizing it comes across as dismissive.
Fear of Vulnerability
Sharing their own “better” story may serve as a shield against feeling exposed or vulnerable, as they redirect attention away from others’ experiences.
Understanding these motivations doesn’t excuse the behavior but can help you approach them with more patience and potentially address the dynamic in a constructive way.
It’s true that many people advise against giving one-uppers a “second chance,” especially in conversations or relationships, because their behavior is often repetitive. This stems from the fact that one-upping is usually a deeply ingrained habit or coping mechanism, and without self-awareness or motivation to change, they are likely to continue doing it.
HERE’S WHY PEOPLE SUGGEST AVOIDING GIVING THEM ANOTHER OPPORTUNITY:
Behavior Patterns Are Consistent
One-uppers rarely stop after just one instance. Their behavior is habitual and can be emotionally draining over time, especially if you value mutual, respectful conversations.
Dismissive Attitude
Repeatedly engaging with a one-upper can make you feel invalidated or unimportant, as they continue to shift focus to themselves.
Lack of Accountability
Many one-uppers don’t realize they’re doing it or don’t see anything wrong with their behavior, making it difficult to resolve the issue.
Emotional Fatigue
Constantly dealing with one-upping can lead to frustration and resentment, especially if they downplay your experiences to highlight their own.
They May Not Be Interested in Changing
Even if confronted, a one-upper might dismiss feedback, reinforcing their pattern. Without introspection, they’ll likely continue the behavior.
That said whether to give them another chance depends on the context and your relationship with them. If it’s a close friend or family member, you might choose to address the behavior and give them room to change. For casual acquaintances or coworkers, it’s often easier to maintain boundaries and limit your interactions. Recognizing the pattern early can save you time and emotional energy.
IT CAN CERTAINLY FEEL THAT WAY, AS ONE-UPPERS OFTEN APPEAR TO PRIORITIZE THEIR OWN STORIES, EXPERIENCES, AND ACCOMPLISHMENTS OVER CONNECTING WITH OTHERS. THEIR BEHAVIOR CAN COME ACROSS AS SELF-CENTERED, WHICH MAKES IT HARD TO BELIEVE THEY GENUINELY CARE. HOWEVER, THE REALITY MAY BE MORE NUANCED:
Self-Focus Over Connection
One-uppers tend to focus on themselves in conversations, which can overshadow any attempts to show care or empathy. This doesn’t necessarily mean they don’t care, but their actions make it difficult for others to see it.
Caring Through Their Lens
Some one-uppers believe they’re relating to you by sharing their own experiences. They may think they’re showing understanding, even if their actions feel dismissive or self-serving.
Struggle to Show Vulnerability
A one-upper may care about others but struggle with vulnerability or emotional openness. They redirect focus to themselves as a defense mechanism, making it seem like they don’t care.
Need for Validation Overshadowing Empathy
Their deep need for validation can overshadow their ability to empathize or prioritize others’ feelings. It doesn’t necessarily mean they’re incapable of caring—it might just not show in the moment.
Unawareness of Impact
Many one-uppers don’t realize how their behavior affects others. They may care about people but lack the self-awareness to recognize how their actions come across.
Genuine Self-Absorption
In some cases, one-upping may stem from genuine narcissistic tendencies or an inability to consider others’ emotions. These individuals may indeed struggle to care deeply about anyone but themselves.
Ultimately, the extent to which a one-upper cares about others depends on the person and their motivations. Some may have the capacity to care deeply but fail to show it effectively, while others may genuinely struggle with prioritizing anyone but themselves. Observing their actions beyond conversations—how they behave in other situations—can offer more clarity.
IF YOU CATCH YOURSELF BEING A ONE-UPPER, IT’S A GREAT STEP TOWARD SELF-AWARENESS AND IMPROVING YOUR INTERACTIONS WITH OTHERS. HERE’S WHAT YOU CAN DO TO BREAK THE HABIT AND BUILD MORE MEANINGFUL CONNECTIONS:
Pause and Reflect
When you feel the urge to share your own story, take a moment to pause. Ask yourself if what you’re about to say contributes to the conversation or if it might overshadow the other person’s experience.
Practice Active Listening
Focus on truly hearing what the other person is saying without planning your response. Nod, make eye contact, and ask follow-up questions to show genuine interest.
Acknowledge the Other Person’s Experience
Instead of responding with a competing story, validate what the other person is sharing. Say things like, “That’s amazing,” or “That sounds really challenging—how did you handle it?”
Resist the Comparison Game
Remind yourself that conversations don’t have to be competitions. You don’t need to prove yourself or your experiences to connect with others.
Apologize if Necessary
If you catch yourself one-upping in the moment, it’s okay to acknowledge it. Say something like, “I realize I just shifted the focus. I’m sorry—please, tell me more about your experience.”
Understand Your Triggers
Reflect on why you feel the need to one-up. Is it insecurity, a desire to fit in, or a habit? Understanding the root cause can help you address it more effectively.
Focus on Building Empathy
Practice putting yourself in the other person’s shoes. Imagine how it feels to share something and have the focus pulled away—it can help motivate you to stay engaged and supportive.
Seek Feedback
If you trust someone close to you, ask for their honest feedback on your conversational habits. They may offer insights you hadn’t noticed.
Celebrate Others’ Wins
Shift your mindset to genuinely celebrate others’ successes and experiences instead of feeling the need to compete.
Be Patient with Yourself
Breaking habits takes time. If you slip up, don’t beat yourself up—acknowledge it and keep working toward better communication.
By being mindful and intentional, you can transform how you engage with others and create more meaningful, balanced conversations.
DEALING WITH A ONE-UPPER CAN BE FRUSTRATING BUT HANDLING THE SITUATION THOUGHTFULLY CAN HELP MAINTAIN YOUR COMPOSURE AND STEER THE CONVERSATION IN A MORE POSITIVE DIRECTION. HERE ARE SOME STRATEGIES:
Stay Calm and Don’t Take It Personally
Recognize that their behavior often stems from insecurity or a need for attention. Avoid letting their actions frustrate or diminish you.
Redirect the Conversation
Gently guide the conversation back to its original topic or another neutral subject. For example, if they hijack the conversation, you might say, “That’s interesting! Now, as I was saying…”
Acknowledge Their Contribution Briefly
Sometimes, a brief acknowledgment can satisfy their need for attention without derailing the conversation. For example, “Wow, that sounds great!” Then continue with your point or involve others in the discussion.
Ask Open-Ended Questions
If you want to diffuse the one-upping without confrontation, ask them questions about their story. It can make them feel heard and prevent further one-upping by satisfying their need to share.
Don’t Engage in the Competition
Resist the urge to one-up them back. Engaging in their behavior will likely escalate the situation and make the interaction more exhausting.
Use Humor to Defuse the Situation
A light, humorous comment can sometimes make them aware of their behavior without being confrontational. For instance, “Wow, it sounds like you’ve done everything!”
Set Boundaries
If their behavior becomes repetitive or draining, set boundaries by limiting your interactions or politely exiting the conversation. For example, “Excuse me, I need to catch up with someone else.”
Address It Directly (If Necessary)
If you have a closer relationship with the person, consider addressing the behavior in a kind and constructive way. Say something like, “I noticed you often share your experiences when I talk about mine. I’d love for us to both have a chance to share.”
Focus on Others in Group Settings
If the one-upper dominates a group conversation, shift attention to others by asking them questions or encouraging them to share.
Decide How Much Energy to Invest
If their behavior consistently drains you and there’s no sign of change, you may need to limit your interactions with them. Protecting your peace is important.
Ultimately, the key is to manage the interaction without letting it negatively affect your mood or self-esteem. Maintaining patience and focusing on positive communication can help minimize the impact of their behavior.
HERE ARE SOME ADDITIONAL ASPECTS OF ONE-UPPERS THAT MAY INTEREST AND HELP YOU:
They Can Be Situational
Not all one-uppers are habitual. Some people might only engage in one-upping in certain scenarios, such as when they feel competitive with a specific person, in professional settings, or in areas where they feel particularly knowledgeable.
They May Not Always Intend to Compete
Some people one-up unintentionally, thinking they’re adding value or relating to the topic. For example, they might think, “If I share my experience, it’ll deepen the conversation,” even though it shifts the focus to themselves.
They Can Alienate Others
Over time, chronic one-upping can lead to social consequences. People may avoid engaging with them because the behavior feels exhausting, leaving the one-upper with fewer meaningful relationships.
It’s Not Always About Bragging
While one-upping often looks like boasting, some one-uppers might do it out of a need to fit in or to mask insecurities, rather than to show off.
They May Struggle with Authentic Connections
By constantly steering conversations toward themselves, one-uppers often miss opportunities to build genuine connections. Their interactions can become transactional rather than relational.
They Can Be Competitive in Other Areas
Beyond conversations, one-uppers may exhibit competitive behaviors in work, hobbies, or even friendships, always striving to “outdo” others in more than just dialogue.
Cultural or Social Norms May Influence Them
In some environments, competitiveness and self-promotion are encouraged or even rewarded (e.g., certain workplaces or social groups). This can exacerbate one-upping behavior, as it becomes normalized.
They Often Lack Self-Awareness
Many one-uppers don’t realize how their behavior affects others. They might think they’re engaging or interesting, but they miss the signs that people feel dismissed or overshadowed.
They May Be Resistant to Change
Addressing one-upping behavior can be challenging. Without a strong motivation to change—such as losing friendships or receiving honest feedback—they may continue the habit indefinitely.
Their Behavior Can Be Triggered by Certain People or Topics
One-uppers may not act this way with everyone. They might feel particularly competitive or insecure around specific individuals, leading to a spike in one-upping in those interactions.
They Might Be Lonely
Ironically, the constant need to assert themselves can leave one-uppers feeling isolated. Their inability to listen and connect deeply can prevent them from forming close relationships, contributing to loneliness.
They Can Be Helped with Patience and Boundaries
If someone is open to feedback, it’s possible to help them become more self-aware and change their behavior. This requires patience and clear communication about how their actions affect others.
ONE-UPPING BEHAVIOR CAN BE QUITE DAMAGING IN RELATIONSHIPS, BOTH PERSONAL AND PROFESSIONAL. IT UNDERMINES TRUST, EMPATHY, AND CONNECTION, WHICH ARE CRUCIAL FOR HEALTHY AND FULFILLING INTERACTIONS. HERE’S HOW ONE-UPPING CAN NEGATIVELY IMPACT RELATIONSHIPS:
Erodes Emotional Intimacy
In close relationships, people want to feel heard and valued. One-uppers often unintentionally dismiss others’ experiences, making the other person feel unimportant or unsupported. This can create emotional distance over time.
Fosters Resentment
Constantly being overshadowed or dismissed can lead to frustration and resentment. The other person may feel their needs and feelings are consistently minimized, which can erode the foundation of the relationship.
Destroys Trust
One-upping often feels competitive rather than collaborative. Over time, the other person may question whether the one-upper truly has their best interests at heart, leading to a breakdown in trust.
Prevents Genuine Connection
Healthy relationships thrive on mutual sharing and understanding. If one person always dominates the conversation, it becomes harder to build a meaningful, reciprocal bond.
Amplifies Conflict
In romantic or close relationships, one-upping can escalate arguments. For instance, if one partner expresses frustration and the other responds with, “You think that’s bad? Let me tell you about my day,” it can invalidate the original concern and escalate tension.
Leads to Communication Breakdown
Over time, the other person may stop sharing their thoughts or feelings, believing their voice won’t be heard or valued. This breakdown in communication can weaken the relationship significantly.
Creates a Toxic Dynamic
In some cases, one-upping can turn into a chronic pattern that dominates the relationship dynamic. It can make the relationship feel one-sided, with one person constantly trying to “win” rather than collaborate.
Reduces Mutual Respect
Respect is key in any relationship. One-uppers often come across as dismissive or condescending, which can lead the other person to feel devalued and unappreciated.
Pushes People Away
Eventually, friends, partners, or colleagues may distance themselves from a one-upper, feeling exhausted or unfulfilled by the relationship. This can leave the one-upper feeling isolated, perpetuating a vicious cycle.
Prevents Conflict Resolution
In disagreements, one-uppers may focus on outdoing their partner rather than resolving the issue. For example, responding to a grievance with, “Well, I’ve dealt with worse,” can sideline the original problem and leave it unresolved.
What Can Be Done?
If you’re in a relationship with a one-upper and want to improve it:
Address the Issue Gently: Point out specific examples of their behavior and how it makes you feel. Use “I” statements, such as, “I feel unheard when our conversations shift focus.”
Set Boundaries: If one-upping becomes overwhelming, make it clear what behaviors are unacceptable and stick to those boundaries.
Encourage Self-Awareness: If they’re willing, suggest they reflect on their behavior and its impact on the relationship.
Consider Professional Help: For deeper issues, couples or individual therapy can be helpful in addressing communication habits and underlying insecurities.
Relationships can survive one-upping if both parties are committed to improving communication and fostering mutual respect.
HERE ARE THE KEY TAKEAWAYS FROM OUR DISCUSSION ABOUT ONE-UPPERS:
Understanding One-Uppers
Motivations Behind One-Upping:
Often driven by insecurity, a need for validation, or a desire to compete for attention.
Some may be unaware of how their behavior affects others.
Signs of a One-Upper:
Habitually turning conversations toward their own experiences.
Minimizing others’ accomplishments or struggles with their “better” or “worse” experiences.
Consistently interrupting to share their own stories.
Impact of One-Upping
Damaging Relationships:
Erodes trust, emotional intimacy, and mutual respect.
Leads to resentment, communication breakdown, and potential social isolation for the one-upper.
Social and Professional Consequences:
People may avoid them due to the exhausting or dismissive nature of their behavior.
Handling One-Uppers
If You Encounter One:
Stay calm and avoid taking their behavior personally.
Redirect the conversation or acknowledge their point briefly before moving on.
Set boundaries or, if appropriate, address the behavior constructively.
If You Find Yourself Being a One-Upper:
Reflect on your motivations and practice active listening.
Focus on showing genuine interest in others’ experiences without turning the spotlight back to yourself.
Deeper Insights
Behavior May Be Situational or Chronic:
Some one-uppers act this way only in specific settings, while others exhibit it more consistently.
They May Be Resistant to Change:
Without self-awareness or external feedback, one-uppers often continue their behavior.
It’s Not Always Malicious:
Some genuinely think they’re contributing to the conversation or trying to relate.
Cultural and Social Norms Can Influence Behavior:
Environments that reward competition or self-promotion may exacerbate one-upping tendencies.
Key Strategies to Keep in Mind
Focus on Empathy: Both in addressing one-uppers and in correcting the behavior in yourself.
Don’t Engage in the Competition: Avoid feeding into the cycle by one-upping back.
Preserve Your Energy: Know when to set boundaries or distance yourself from persistent one-uppers.
Remember, the key to handling one-uppers or addressing the tendency in yourself is to focus on listening, mutual respect, and building meaningful connections. Whether you encounter one in your life or catch yourself slipping into the habit, awareness and thoughtful communication are the first steps toward improvement.
TO EXPLORE MORE ABOUT ONE-UPPERS AND THEIR BEHAVIOR, YOU CAN REFER TO A RANGE OF SOURCES ACROSS BOOKS, ARTICLES, AND PSYCHOLOGY RESOURCES. HERE ARE SOME PLACES WHERE YOU CAN FIND MORE INFORMATION:
1. Psychology Books on Communication and Relationships
Books that delve into human behavior, communication, and interpersonal dynamics often discuss one-upping as part of broader topics like narcissism, insecurity, or emotional intelligence. Some recommendations include:
- “The Social Animal” by Elliot Aronson
- “How to Win Friends and Influence People” by Dale Carnegie
- “The Art of Communicating” by Thich Nhat Hanh
- “Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life” by Marshall B. Rosenberg
2. Psychological and Relationship Blogs/Articles
Websites that specialize in psychology, relationships, or social behavior often feature articles on one-upping. A few sites to consider:
- Psychology Today (psychologytoday.com): Search for articles on competitive behavior, narcissism, or emotional intelligence.
- MindTools (mindtools.com): A great resource for workplace communication and understanding interpersonal dynamics.
- VeryWell Mind (verywellmind.com): Focuses on mental health and behavior, often discussing issues like narcissism or self-esteem.
3. Research Papers and Journals
For a deeper dive, consider looking at academic research papers that explore behaviors related to competitiveness, narcissism, and interpersonal communication. You can access these on platforms like:
- Google Scholar (scholar.google.com): Search for research on narcissism, competitive behaviors, or communication styles.
- JSTOR (jstor.org): Offers academic papers on psychology and human behavior, often covering topics related to one-upping.
4. Podcasts and Videos
- TED Talks: There are numerous TED Talks about communication, behavior, and relationships, which can help you better understand the psychology behind one-upping.
- The School of Life (YouTube): They produce insightful videos on emotional intelligence, social dynamics, and personal growth.
5. Books on Narcissism and Insecurity
Since one-upping can often be linked to narcissistic tendencies or deep-seated insecurities, books on these topics can provide context for understanding one-upping behavior:
- “Rethinking Narcissism” by Craig Malkin
- “The Narcissism Epidemic” by Jean M. Twenge and W. Keith Campbell
- “The Gifts of Imperfection” by Brené Brown
6. Self-Help and Personal Growth Resources
Many self-help books and resources also touch on how to develop healthy communication skills and how to avoid one-upping. For example:
- “Radical Acceptance” by Tara Brach
- “The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work” by John M. Gottman (though geared toward relationships, many principles apply to general social interactions)
7. Online Courses and Workshops
If you’re looking for structured learning, consider online courses related to improving communication, emotional intelligence, or understanding social behaviors. Platforms such as:
- Coursera (coursera.org)
- Udemy (udemy.com)
- LinkedIn Learning (linkedin.com/learning)
8. Support Forums and Discussion Groups
Online communities such as Reddit or specialized forums on psychology and relationships often have discussions where people share experiences with one-uppers and explore strategies for dealing with them.
- Reddit (reddit.com): Subreddits like r/relationships, r/AskReddit, and r/socialskills offer valuable insights.
These sources will provide both theoretical understanding and practical strategies for dealing with one-uppers in various social settings.
If you liked this Share It!
Unleash your BOHOtude – visit BOHOtude Apparel for a selection of free-spirited apparel.